Welcome to the Carpetguru's question and answer forum. I used to try and answer questions by email, but the volume of email has increased to the point to where I was answering many of the same questions. By using this forum, I hope to answer your questions as well as creating a sense of community. Here you can ask the guru any questions concerning carpet, carpet pad, vinyl flooring, laminate flooring, and hardwoods.
Also, if you have an installation question or problems I will discuss it with you here for all to see. To Reach the latest comment click on the comment link below, and then when the screen changes, click on the newest. If you are having trouble reading this blog you can leave a comment at www.facebook.com/carpetguru.CarpetClassics
Thank You,
Jim
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)
2,566 comments :
«Oldest ‹Older 1801 – 2000 of 2566 Newer› Newest»Hello. I am carpeting my son's bedroom. Low traffic. Thinking about using a frieze that has the pad attached. It wouldn't need to be stretched, so I could do it myself to save some money. Would this last several years? Thanks.
Karen
I think you mean "triexta" a new fiber from Mohawk. This a a super fiber for families with pets and teens. It has built in stain resistance, and will not fade.
In order to not show foot prints too much you need to purchase a frieze, not a shag. Keep the pile height to three quarter inch or less, and the twist level high.
8lb rebond pad is a good pad, and ten pound density my be too firm to your liking. If you purchase a Mohawk carpet, check into purchasing "smartcushion" which will double your Mohawk Warranty.
Good Luck,
Jim
Karen,
If you can find a frieze with the pad attached, and is not made from olefin fiber, then go for it. The attached pad that is branded "kanga" would be best.
Good Luck,
Jim
Thanks for the information on the pad. Tigressa is the brand we are considering from Carpet One. Here is the link
http://www.carpetone.com/flooringinformation/ourbrands/carpet.aspx
Dear Carpet Guru,
I would truly appreciate your insight when it comes to carpet cleaning. We are looking to get our carpets professionally cleaned and i am debating between what I have used before - steam cleaning with hot water, or another method I have heard about which is dry cleaning with the HOST system which is supposed to have all sorts of pros but is a bit more expnsive. I'd appreciate your views on the best method to use. Thanks!
Chris
According to your link to Carpet One, the fiber in question appears to be their answer to Tactesse nylon from Stainmaster. Their information does not say if the nylon is type 6.6 like Stainmaster, or type 6 like Anso, wear dated, and all other nylons.
You should not be influenced by softness so much. More important is density and twist level.
I would still check out Mohawks Smartstrand for your job. The very nature of the fiber is perfect for your family room. Just be sure to find a well constructed carpet.
Good Luck,
Jim
Steam cleaning is the method recommended by most mills in order to keep your warranty.
Host is a powder that once placed on the carpet is impossible to totally remove, and repeated use of the product has been known to make the carpet impossible to clean due to build up of the particles.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi Jim,
Thanks for taking the time to create this site. I have spent lots of time reading it.
I'm looking to replace the carpeting in my basement. I have 3 kids who play down there and I know there will be food and drink spills. I like the look of a loop carpeting and have narrowed it down to two carpets. The first one is Shaw's
52P13 Traditional Elegance 100% Evertouch BCF nylon with RX2 stainguard. The second is Karastan's Sicilian Coast made with Smartstrand. The loops on the Karastan are larger and I worry that they will snag but I love the Smartstrand story. In your opinion which one will wear and clean up better?
Thanks for all you help!
-Brenda
Brenda,
You are right, the loops in the Karastan product are too loose, and this type of construction will tend to crush more quickly than the Shaw product.
The R2X stain treatment is very good, and you will like the long term result for this style.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi Jim,
Thanks for your advice on the Karastan vs. Shaw. I love the look and feel of the Shaw Traditional Elegance but am now wondering if there is a more appropriate carpet for my situation. I have been struggling for over 6 months on the carpet selection and want to make sure I choose the right one.
Could you put an end to my agony and recommend a specific carpet (brand and name) and pad for me? I would like a nylon loop/berber that will hold up and clean well for 10 years that will be installed in my basement over a concrete floor. It will be my children and their friends who primarily use it.
Thanks again for your advice,
Brenda
Hi Carpetguru,
We're replacing our carpets and got several recommendations from carpet stores: Shaw ClearTouch Filament PET carpet, Shaw Anso Nylon, Hollytex Solution Dyed Nylon, and Mohawk SmartStrand. The rooms are medium to high traffic area, and we have a 70 lbs dog. Which one would you recommend? We like the Frieze style, how do you think it'll do well with the traffic and our dog?
Thanks,
Hao
Brenda,
Look at a solution dyed nylon berber from Beaulieu called Brocade . This carpet is best installed over a slab rubber pad.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hao,
Your best choice is a SmartStrand frieze like 'Atlantic Shores' by Horizon (a Mohawk Mill)
Your next best choice is Park Ave 2 from Beaulieu. This is a solution dyed nylon frieze.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi guru,
Thanks for the quick response. The store has Karastan "Wilderness Retreat" Smartstrand in stock @$2.69/sf (carpet only). What do you think of the fit and value? I see you have good words on Anso Nylo in your website, can you share the reason not recommending it in my case?
Thanks,
Hao
Hao,
The Karastan product is a good buy, and is better because the stain resistance will always be a part of the Smartstrand product.
Good Luck,
Jim
WOW!! What a great site!! Buying carpet is very confusing.
We are redoing our bedroom and are looking at the Smartstrand by Mohawk.
We need it to wear well but most of all stain resistant as much as possible. We have 2 cats and sometimes they will throw up.
Any suggestions?
You have chosen wisely. Smartstrand is ideal for your needs. Try and check out some of the styles by Mohawks Aladdin division for best buys.
Good Luck,
Jim
Is Puresque Carpet by Beaulieu of America actually good for people like me who suffer from indoor and outdoor allergies like it suggests?
Puresque carpet is treated with an anti bacterial agent in the backing. This is good for stopping bacterial growth; not build up of allergens like pet dander. Also, if you have a severe latex allergy, I would suggest you look at woven carpets only.
Good Luck,
Jim
Thank you in advance for your help! We just moved in, need to replace master bd on downstairs; and stairway and all of upstaris to include hallway and 3 bedrooms. 2 young teenage girls. We are looking at the Carefree Living 2818 South Beach. I am concerned that it is not nlyon. Will the PET be ok? The wieght is much more than the nylon we looked at plus it has Luxury Bac & Magic Fresh. Should we just spend a little more for the nylon at a lesser wt? The difference was only $300 for the whole house. The nylon did not have the luxury bac if that even matters.
Again, thank you.
PET is not as strong as nylon, but if the pile is short and tightly twisted, it will perform well. I am not sure that the backing system will make much difference. Magic Fresh is a nice feature, but not THE reason to make a purchase. The first place you will notice the difference between the two fibers is on the stairwary.
Hope this helps.
BTW make sure the pile length is not too long, as you don't want the pile to crush out.
Jim
Thank you for your informative website and forum!!!
We are installing carpet in a basement that will get lots of traffic due to kids and grandkids. The carpet will go down the stairs. A high priority for me is that traffic patterns don't show and stain resistence. Are nylon and triexta comparable or would one wear better in a frieze than the other? I was looking at Mohawk 100% smartstrand triexta frieze or a nylon frieze from Bliss ("best" or "premium") .
The difference between the two, nylon and triexta, is a matter of construction. The best constructed carpet of the two will wear longer. The triexta, however, will always be a better choice for stain resistance.
Good Luck
Jim
Thank you for a very informative web site! I'm looking to replace carpet in a house I plan to sell in 5 years. It's in the $150-160,000 price range. The carpet I'm looking at is a Beaulieu Coronet 100% permasoft BCF nylon with a woven polypropylene backing. I can't tell if it's solution dyed for fadability. The retailer is suggesting a 6 lb. pad all through out. I also looked at a Triesta and they said it will tend to get fuzzy over time. I have 2 teenagers and a small dog. Do you think the nylon is an appropriate product for us at $30 per square yard?
The Tirexta will be a better choice, and it will not fuzz or shed, as it is a continuous filament fiber. The tips of all fibers will loosen over time, and that is why twist is important.
For the money, I'd look at a Aladdin (Mohawk) product called "front runner". This triexta carpet, will clean up super and look new when time to sell the home.
Good Luck,
Jim
I am having my carpet installed as we speak. It is a frieze, I can pick it up an inch or more off of the padding, at any point in the room. Is this normal? Thank you!
Only if the room is bigger than 18 x 18. Some shags are easy to grab a hold of, and therefore easy to pick up off the floor. If the full travel is over an inch and the room is small, get the installer to sign an installation warranty.
Good Luck,
Jim
we need a thin carpet , commercial type nylon with all plastic materials, so that moisture will not give off a odour, as does cloth type materials ie jute burlap etc.
we have a hot yoga studio and for years have used carpet as it is safer when water hits the floor it does not make a skating rink as wood or laminate does. we don,t want students slipping,, the only problem is the occasional odour we think that comes from the jute not being plastic.we have cement floor 1500 sq ft use radiant heat at high temps so moisture evaporates within an hour at tops and constant air exchange. its time to change the flooring and we want the best so we don,t get that odour of carpet moisture like a wet dog all suggestions would be so helpful
Many of the commercial carpets on the market are available with "unitary" back. This system is designed for direct glue down installation. This will meet your needs. However, the only rub is the selection of the glue used to install the carpet. Be sure to explain to your contractor that you have radiant heat in the floor, and that the carpet does get wet. Improper glue will result in floor failure, and in unpleasant odors.
Good luck,
Jim
You stated that "The difference between the two, nylon and triexta, is a matter of construction. The best constructed carpet of the two will wear longer."
How does one tell which is better constructed by looking at them?
I have been installing carpet for about 15 years since the age of 14 when I could first start riding with dad to work in the summers. I have heard here and there through the years that you need to seam seal carpet before putting it together. What exactly does this consist of? We have never had a problem with a seam so this is why I ask.
You can tell a great deal about the quality of a carpet by examining the twist level, the stitch rate, and the pile length. The tighter the twist , the better, the closer the stitch rate the better, Pile length is important depending on the effect you want. Longer shag like construction will look different under high traffic than the shorter more dense pile. Triexta and nylon carpets of similar construction will perform about the same. The triexta will have the edge when it comes to stain resistance.
Good Luck,
Jim
Heath,
Seam sealing is done to keep the carpet from loosing tufts at seams subjected to foot traffic. If you use just the goo from the melted heat tape, you will not get a good "seal" as the seam.
The CRI says that all seams will be sealed with a seam sealant that contains a dye marker. This gives carpet inspectors a means to check for the sealant using a "black light" If there is ever a complaint filed by the consumer, and the mill sends out a certified inspector, it is possible for the mill to deny the claim based on non compliance with CR-105.
I have seen this happen to some of my competitors. It is up to you if you want to risk taking the time to perform this extra step during your installation.
Good Luck,
Jim
Wow I did not realize this. Where do I get the sealer with dye in it? I am assuming I flip the carpet over before the seam and run a bead along each edge. Is there possibly a video on this to help see exactly how it is done? Some installers have claimed they put it on one edge as they push the iron forward.
Thanks for everything!
Heath,
I think Roberts makes one. Check with your professional installation supplier.
Good Luck,
Jim
What do you think of Resista carpet? Also what padding? The saleman says they go thin padding now-a-days. Do I believe this? This is a great site !
Resista is a private label name for PET polyester. It is not a "better" PET polyester. Depending on construction, your Resista carpet may or may not perform.
As for padding, yes, it has been established by the CRI that padding thicker than 1/2 inch could be detrimental to a long lasting installation. The optimum thickness as been suggested at 7/16th inch.
Good Luck,
Jim
As a consumer, what questions do I ask the dealer/installer (same folks) about the installation? Can I just specify in the contract that it will be done in accordance with CR105 ? or should I ask and write into the contract specific questions? I want it done right.
(right enough that Holmes on Homes would be proud to have it in his house.)
What should those questions be?
Thanks
If you ask your dealer to put into your sales contract that the carpet be installed according to CR-105, then you will be covered.
You can print out this document at: www.carpet-rug.org/pdf_word_docs/105.pdf -
Good Luck,
Jim
This site is nothing less than magnificent!!! Thank you for your advice and counsel.
I am re-carpeting my home. Three young children, two cats, two adults. I am looking at Mohawk SmartStrand (twist: 5.5; density: 1653; face weight 34.5) and what appears to be an identical Resista product (twist: 5.75; density: 1602; and face weight 34.3). The Resista is "100% BCF Resista Polyester" and the Mohawk is "100% SmartStrand BCF Triexta".
I've heard that Polyester doesn't hold up to high traffic and will show wear, but both these product tout 10 year warranties on texture, stain, and abrasive wear.
I am confused and just want a decent casual wear carpet that will last ~10 years.
PLEASE weigh in! :)
Thanks in advance,
Erin
Erin,
Triextra and PET are not going to perform the same. The specs you gave will work great for the Triexta product.
You cannot judge by the warranties offered by the mills, as they tend to over state the carpet's capabilities. The key to making any of your choices last is to keep the carpet clean. Mohawk, for example, wants you to have your carpet cleaned every 18 months. This will keep the fibers from getting sticky feeling, and thus matting down.
You will pay a little more for the extra soft Triexta,, but you can find some good values in the triexta fiber that is not quite as soft in the Aladdin line from Mohawk.
Good Luck,
Jim
CarpetGuru! Fantastic site! I have been told a few things regarding pad with an install - Some people have told me that carpet installed or tackstrip without padding will void a carpets warranty...is this true?
If you do not install new tufted carpet over a new pad that is at least 5 lb density and 3/8ths thick, then you will not have a warranty from the mill. The exception to this are commercial carpets that are designed for "direct glue down" installation.
Good Luck,
Jim
8/5/10
Dear Guru - I have a small piece of carpet and upon the back is stamped:
Philadelphia Backing Systems. It has a rubberized backing that would do well on my hardwood floors, but I do not know the brand of carpet or carpets that have such a backing. Regular broadlooms have such brittle, nasty backs that leave waffle marks on my floors that are murder to get off. Any ideas??
Thank you, you do good work for consumers.
The backing system you mention is most often found on "bath carpet", and you will not find broadloom carpet with such backing.
You can purchase broadloom carpets with Shaw's SoftBac. This will not make marks on your hardwood, however, the rug may move all over the place.
There are pads that will keep your rug in place, but you may be back to leaving "waffle" marks on your floor.
NoMov pad company makes a pad that is rubber coated on one side, and "velcro" like on the other. This pad keeps your area rug in place, and should have minimal effect on your hardwood floor.
Good Luck,
Jim
Great site!. I would like your opinion on 100% Nylon 6 Shaw Green Edge Queen carpet with a performance rating of 4. Carpet has dense short pile (approx 1/2") with a tight twist, R2X soil and stain resistance and SoftBac. 52 square yards of carpet is to be installed in 1/2 of family room of split level home on concrete floor - other half of room is tiled. Local store gave me a price of $1850 for carpet, installation and 6lb rebond pad that meets Shaw's warranty requirements. We have 4 grown children (1 college aged living at home) and 4 grandchildren. We enter home on tile floor hallway so much of shoe dirt is gone before walking across carpet to upstairs - but this is still a traffic path. Is this a good choice for wear? I don't want it to mat. Is padding adequate or do you suggest something else? I appreciate your assistance. Stu
Stu,
The fact that the carpet carries a par rating of 4 is enough proof that the carpet will perform. The fact that it is nylon is good for wear.
A six pound rebond is the minimum suggested, but if you are going to be in the home more than ten years, I would consider upgrading to an 8 lb pad.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hello, I've read on other sites where warranties were void because of the type of vacuum used, especially on frieze carpet. I think the advice was to turn off the roller brush/beater bar. IMO, that wouldn't sufficiently clean the carpet. I'm leaning toward Smartstrand frieze and also plan on investing in a well-made vacuum that should hopefully last the life of the carpet, i.e. Sebo or Miele. Any advice on vacuuming the different fibers and if warranties are affected? Thank you.
Your concern about vacuums is noted. Some of the longer shag type carpets made from very soft fiber have had problems with beater bars in some vacuums. Mile is a great vacuum, and would work with almost all carpets.
If your carpet has a par rating of 3.5 or more, you should not worry about vacuum type.
Good Luck,
Jim
i am looking at a new carpet product called Tigressa, Art of Softness II made by Shaw, from Carpet One. I have not heard alot about this carpet. Is it better an Mohawk softstrand triexta? Tigressa claims to be better and softer. What is youur opinion.
Also I need a very good carpet pad. I have a bad back and need the cushion.
The "Tigressa" is Shaw's version of Soft nylon and is sold to Carpet One dealers as a marking device. It is basically Anso Caress nylon without the Anso label.
It is not as fade resistant as Triexta, There is more hype about Tigressa than substance, and the only reason to purchase it is because you have fallen in love with the color and softness.
Smartstrand, on the other hand, is more fade resistant, and more cleanable. Wear performance will be about the same as the nylon if you are comparing equal constructions .
A high quality 8lb rebond pad will be a good pad in most cases.
Good Luck,
Jim
Have you heard anything more about the Tigressa carpet from Shaw that Carpet One sells? I am just wondering as it gets great reviews online. Or do you feel the Lee carpet Tatanium series would be better? They also sell the Mohawk smart cushion 8 lb pad. The other choice I have is from a locally owned carpet store which sells the frothed foam 8lb. pad and two carpets that I also like.. One the Hollytex ultimate performance series called Reliance and the other a tuftex carpet *so far away* series. I live in the country and have three cats so I would appreciate your input.. thank you so much.. JH
JH.
Of the carpets you have chosen, the Hollytex is your best choice as it is a solution dyed nylon. This fiber is as stain resistant as Triexta, and also fade resistant and very strong. This carpet is a great choice.
You can install over froth foam only if you know for sure that you are going to be in the home for more than ten years. If not, you can use a good 8 lb rebond pad like SmartPad or similar.
Good Luck,
Jim
Thank your for this site. I have used in shopping for carpet and sure makes it easier to only be shown what you ask for. I am down to 2 choices: #1 a locally owned well-respected shop for StainMaster 100% solution dyed BCF 750 sq ft total install price of $2100. #2 Carpet One similar for Stainmaster, but salesman pushed Lee's "No Exclusions" Ultra 25® Stain Warranty which covers stains other carpet warranties don't: pet stains, grease, mustard, coffee, cola and more; it is 100% BCF nylon, for $3,100 total install. The quesion is - is it worth it? I'm thinking not; but I am intrigued by this "no exclusions" warranty. Thanks in advance!
Hello,
I am building a new house and the builder is offering Mohawk Portico carpet. My dilemma is whether I should go with the Frieze or Plush style. I have 2 young kids and a small non-shedding dog. I really don't like the look of the Frieze since it looks like it has 2 different colors based on the direction the carpet is lying (it looks a bit busy to me). I like the neater look of the plush style. However, I have read that Frieze holds up better over time. The carpet will be placed in the living room, family room, whole upstairs (hallway, bedrooms and loft), stairs, and finished basement. Both offer a 10 year warranty. Which do you advise that I go with?
Your selection of Hollytex Reliance carpet is a great one, and the price you were quoted is very fair. I would use HC pad, as it is even superior to the Shaw Froth foam.
Remember no pad is totally pet proof, but you are doing all you can with your current choices. Just make sure you professionally clean the carpet every two years to keep your warranties in play.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jen,
Go with the plush, as it will always be in style. Just purchase as dark a color as you can stand. This helps hide general soiling.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim, what is the difference between hc pad and shaw's frothed foam pad?
HC pad is made from corm oil and only has one moisture barrier. The froth foam from Shaw is made from petroleum and has a double moisture barrier.
Both are "memory foam" and are made 7/16ths inch thick. Both have very low or vocs. Both are about the same price.
Good Luck,
Jim
I recently bought a home with Brazilian Cherry hardwood floors. What is the best method to maintain it?
Jim could you please let me know if $9 a yard is a good price for the 7/16 healty choice pad? If not what would be a good price.. that is just for the pad and not having it installed. Thank you again.. you've been such a great help :)
JH
Since there are so many different woods that are called "Brazilian Cherry", I have no idea of the quality of the wood you have. I would ask your supplier this question.
In general wood floors need to be protected from grit and sand, high heal shoes, and harmful liquids.
Good Luck,
Jim
I installed commercial carpet tile over the concrete floor in my basement. The glue was supposedly low-VOC but still had a strong odor to it. That mostly passed after 1-2 weeks.
The glue has never totally dried though I assume that's how it should be so that I can pull up the tiles.
But, on damp or humid days I still get what seems like a bit of the odor from the glue. The basement has never been wet but I've read that small amounts of moisture can still migrate up through the concrete.
I'm wondering if that is the problem and if using glue meant for outdoor carpet would not have this problem since it can get wet. I'd probably have a harder time replacing a tile but that's no big deal.
But, getting the glue off the floor will be a major job. I already had to do that once when I replaced the carpet the previous owners put down. And that glue had not dried a year after I moved in.
The carpet manufacturer (who also makes the adhesive) has been no help. Any thoughts?
If you used glue designed for commercial carpet tiles, then you will always have a faint glue smell unless your area covered is huge; i.e. hotel lobby, airport, school. In a smaller room like a residential basement, there is never enough ventilation to stave off some vapor smells.
Good luck,
jim
I am about to purchase a 83 oz nylon carpet (156 yards) having it installed over a 8 pound 3/8 inch thick rebonded pad. Is this a good match? There are two adults and one cat in the family but it is a bylevel home so everyone comes up the stairs to the living area. The dealer quoted me about $7,000 to do the job. How does that sound to you?
You did not say what type of carpet your 83 ounce carpet is. Is it a shag, a plush, or what. Is the 83 ounces the face weight of the carpet or the total weight of the carpet.
It would also be good to know if the nylon is branded i.e. Stainmaster or Wear Dated, or Anso Caress???
In general, 3/8th is a little thin for a pad. 7/16th is the standard for such an install.
Give me more info, and I will be better able to answer your question.
Good Luck,
Jim
I just installed new engineered floor and want to put an area carpets down for the dog (he has trouble walking on hardwood floors). The engineered floor manufacture recommends a carpet with a soft synthetic backing which allows the floor to breath. What types of carpet or padding would you recommend?
Most often you will want a rug and pad combo that will not allow the rug to move all over the place. The key is the pad. Look for special pads from the NoMuv corp. that have a rubber coating on one side and a "velcro-like" surface on the other. This pad is especially designed for area rugs over smooth hardwood floors.
As far as having a carpet and pad combo that will breathe, this should not be necessary unless you are covering over 80 percent of the hardwood area with one rug.
Good Luck,
Jim
To Jim,
I have Beaulieu carpet "Embraceable You" that is about 10 months old. I feel a slight crunch to it when walked on with bare feet. It is not limited to higher wear areas, and I don't recall it to be crunchy when it was newer. We always take our shoes off and only 3 people live here. Could the crunch be normal. Other than that it is wearing great. (Carpet is nylon with softbac). Any thoughts? Thanks
You should not be experiencing any crunch sounds from your carpet. Most likely it is the pad. Sometimes rebond and other pads with a moisture barrier can create a crunching sound when the moisture barrier comes loose from the pad itself.
Have your dealer check it out, as you may have a possible pad replacement claim.
Good Luck,
Jim
Considering Shaw Passageway 111 carpet, an Evertouch BCF Nylon, with polyprophlene backing. Salesman says 8lb rebond with antimicrobial is okay, but I'm considering the Shaw Triple Touch urethane. Installation is over concrete floor in split level (below grade by 4 feet). Is the Triple Touch worth it? Joan
I'm looking at Mohawk Horizon 1I50 Intelligent style and Karastan Ebraceable both with Smart Strand. We are replacing carpet in entire house (183 yards). We currently have a trackless textured carpet that has held up well even in high traffic areas (Weardated II) purchased 12 years ago (replacing due to old dog and soiling at end and some matting in high traffic areas).
My husband is concerned about track marks from the vacuum.
What are your comments regarding these two carpets. I don't have spec. sheet for the Karastan but understand that it is 80 oz compared with the Intelligent Style which is 58.8 oz.
Two adults and springer spaniel. Want to get the best carpet possible and hope not to replace for at least 15 years.
I am looking for late October installation. I thought I saw on web that Karastan usually goes on sale in October.
What would be a reasonable rate be for carpet, 10 lb moisture resistant pad, installation labor and tear out and haul away in a resort type location where labor is always higher!
I'm looking at Carpet One and also online. Still looking for a good carpet installer as the guy who installed 12 years ago retired.
Joan,
Passageway is a good choice. You did not say if it was passageway one, two, or three; all are good.
Use a pad that does not have a moisture barrier because you are installing over concrete. Triple touch pad has two moisture barriers, and I do not think you need it, especially over concrete.
Good Luck,
Jim
Both Smartstrand products are going to do the job. I think the Karastan product is closer to 70 ounces than 80 ounces.
Install over froth foam or 100 ounce slab rubber only if you know you are gong to be in the home 15 years or more. Otherwise, an 8 lb rebond is great.
If you are gong to use your own installer, then you will be able to buy the carpet at a reduced price, as most dealers will work with you on a "cash n carry" sale. However, there are some risks buying carpet his way, i.e. no warranty from the dealer.
I have no idea of prices on these carpets, as prices vary greatly from dealer to dealer, and State to State.
Freight rates are higher for dealers on the West Coast.
Before you buy "online" made sure they send you a sample of the carpet for you to compare when your shipment arrives at your home.
Good Luck,
Jim
Thanks in advance for taking time to answer so many questions for everyone. Here is mine.... It is a long story!
We purchased carpet from a big box store that was manufactured by a well known company. It was not a stain master fiber, but a manufacturers equivalent. After being installed with a 1/2" rebond moisture barrier pad we were excited to move in. We had been remolding for 6 months at this point and carpet was the final peg in the cog. Within a week of the carpet being installed, I began to experience slight headaches and disorientation. We had yet to move in at this point. Another week went by and I began having dried out sinuses that lead to bad headaches and within an hour of that a sore throat! We had left every window in the house open 24 hours a day to air out.
I contacted the manufacturer after a few more weeks who in return contacted the big box store. The manufacturer sent an independent flooring inspector to take samples of both carpet and pad to send to the manufacturer. This was a friday afternoon 4th of july weekend. By tuesday the 5th, we were contacted by the big box store in response from the manufacturer. We were instructed to go pick out a new carpet (Not made by the same company???)and the manufacturer would pay for the tear out and installation of new carpet. They also wanted all the carpet rolled up and sent back to them! The carpet we chose to replace this was by an even bigger name company!!!!! We also got an upgrade from the pad company to a polyurethane moister barrier pad (made without formaldehyde). It took roughly two months from the first installation to get the carpet removed and the "other" new carpet installed. At this point the air in the house was so toxic it was like someone had gassed the house. This was with every window open and every fan we had running.
Beginning of august is when the installers came to remove the carpet. They stated that they have become so used to carpet over 20 years that they never are affected by it! That was before they were done! By the time they drug all the carpet and pad out, they both had bad headaches and disorientation. One said he has never had that experience before!
Now it appears the new carpet has the same problems! Its been a month and a half and we are still not moved in. We have been airing out this new carpet with all windows open, furnace fan running, exhaust fans blazing and box fans blowing. I cant be in the house for more than a half hour before I get sinus irritation and mild headaches! It smells like a someone is spraying chemical fumes into our house. If I stay in the non-carpet areas I will normalize, but when I move to carpet areas my symptoms come back! I was working everyday in this house for months before the carpet was installed with ABSOLUTELY NO symptoms like this!
We have vacuumed over and over! We have tried zeolite! I am so frustrated! I am afraid to move into the house, for fear of brain damage or some health effect! My symptoms are all the known symptoms of formaldehyde! And the sinus irritation has been linked to nasal cancer after extended exposure.
Can you PLEASE help us. Can this be remedied by steam cleaning or something. We are desperate! We want to enjoy the fruits of our labor, blood, sweat and tears! I will try anything. It baffles me that anyone could live in such an environment.
Thanks you much,
Adam
Wow, so much information! Our home was hit in June by a tornado. We now have to select replacement carpet. Our contractor sent us to a particular vendor he works with a great deal. That vendor is really pushing the Resista line. Basically he didn't show me anything else. Perhaps its because its what he thinks is best for us, but never having shopped for carpet like this before, I feel unsure. We had three different carpets in the house prior to the tornado and he recommends I selevt only one and run it through all the carpetted areas. Besides reading your site, where would you start if you were in my shoes? Any thoughts on the Resista lines? We intend to be in this house a long time, have 4 children, two large dogs and live on a farm (translates lots of dust,dirt etc.) Thank you for helping me get started. Jill
A follow up to my earlier question about starting to buy carpet. When the old carpet and pad was removed, the old staples were not pulled. The contractor and the carpet distributor said its normal to install over them. Seems that would be destructive to the new pad. Is this the norm, if installation is everything? Jill
Adam,
Your story, thankfully, is rare. I have found that the fiber is not the cause of your problem. It is most likely the latex used to hold the two backs of the carpet together. Also, Shaw is putting more florocarbon on their carpet these days in an effort to make their "lifetime stain" warranty more workable.
I had one case this past summer that was similar to yours, but not quite as severe. It took a week of airing out the home to bring VOCs in line.
I am not sure cleaning the carpet would help, but it may. If you can get the mill to pay for it, I'd try it. Use no soap, just steam.
You may have to install laminate flooring all over, and use wool woven area rugs on top.
Factors that make VOCs worse are high room temperature, high humidity, low air movement, concrete floor, and lack of ventilation.
I am sorry I can't be of more help, but your Big Box store should still be willing to help solve your problem.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jill,
Resista is a brand name of PET polyester, and in general is less durable that carpets made from nylon or Triexta.
For family living, I would suggest a two or three tone carpet made from Triexta (Smartstrand) or nylon. Stay away from anything too shaggy, and the tighter the twist the denser the better.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jill,
According to CR-105 (our industry installation "bible"), it is required that the floor be prepared by removing old staples, glues, etc, from the floor before installing new padding.
BTW, failure to follow CR-105 could give your carpet mill a reason to deny a future claim. Also, reasons to deny claims include lack of power stretching, and lack of seam sealer at the seams.
Good Luck,
Jim
How Long Does factory fiber protection last on standard berber
Hi. I am about to go through with a purchase of carpet and am confused about the pad I am being offered.
Despite the recommendations I have read to use no more than 7/16 for residential, my guy is offering me an 8lb 1/2" rebond pad from Future Foam. He says a 7/16 pad would be special order and would cost more.
Question - will I be ok with the 1/2" or will it be better to push for a 7/16? Is Future Foam good brand?
FYI - the carpet is Tigressa Wrapped in Softness and Worlds of Softness
Do not worry about using the 1/2 pad instead of 7/16th as the actual pad that arrives at your home could vary in thickness between the two. 8 lb density is good.
BTW your Shaw soft nylon carpet should come with a warranty booklet. See if the warranty booklet specifically requires 7/16ths pad.
Good Luck,
Jim
If your "standard berber" was made from olefin fiber, then the soil protection does not matter, as this carpet will soil from the day its installed.
Most soil protection is shampooed out in two commercial cleanings.
Good luck,
Jim
Recommend (please) a very good, very durable berber carpet for a high traffic area with 2 pets and 3-4 humans. Name, brand, manufacturer ... I'm ready to give up and live with the old stuff!
HERE IS WHAT I HAVE FOUND THAT I LIKE:
Looking only for neutral color - so am flexible.
I liked one the dealer says was made by Shaw - but branded by the store (the name they've given is SUMMIT, St. Croix, 15 year warranty, 10 year wear and 10 year stain, 48 oz. face weight, 100% BCF Nylon, Small square texture -repeat 5/8 x 3/4.)
I can NOT find it again anywhere. Would like to price shop.
A super berber for your situation would be a piece made by Hollytex (a division of Beaulieu of America) called Brocade 2. This is a two ply looped berber in solid colors made from solution dyed nylon pile. This carpet is most resistant to fading, pet stains, and will wear a long time.
Install over at least an 8 lb rebond, and made sure the installer power stretches all rooms.
Good Luck,
Jim
This is the best product site run by an objective (not the manufacurer) person I have ever seen. You are to be congratulated. We have a Family Partnership and over the past two years we have purchased two Flooring companies and we will be a frequent user of the knowledge that is contained in your site.
Jim Shanahan
Jim,
Thank you for visiting carpetguru.com, and for you kind words. My main purpose in this blog and the website is to give the consumer a fighting chance so they will not waste their hard earned dollars when purchasing carpet and installation.
Good luck with your new ventures,
Jim
Question - We have been presented a Bliss by Beaulieu nylon carpet 50 ounce face weight with Magic Fresh. What is your opinion on that carpet? I am most interested in comparing it to Smart Strand. We have an option of a 20 pound pad I have yet to see and a 1/2 inch 8 pound Future Foam "Peak Plus". We have 2 kids and a big dog. What do you think about our options?
Thanks!
Melissa
Melissa,
While Bliss is a great line of carpet, I have no clue as to the type of carpet. 50 ounces in a shag would not do well as a 40 ounce dense plush. Your Bliss nylon will wear well, but if stain resistance is a high priority, then a 50 ounce Smartstrand plush would be better.
From your description, it appears that you are looking at a slab rubber padding. This is an excellent pad, and it will last a long time. If you choose Smartstrand, you may want to look at "Smartpad" by Mohawk. This pad will double your Smartstand warranty.
Good Luck,
Jim
I am planning to carpet three bedrooms ,loft area and two flights of stairs in a condo we are renovating. It will be used for vacations and skiing. The stairs will be the the most heavy traffic area. No carpet in the entry way or main living area except area carpets.
I am interested in the Sarona Smartstrand. The local dealer carries only a few choices. My hometown dealer has great selection but the names do not match. Is there a main source where the local dealer (NH) can find the carpet my hometown(RI) carries,?
Is the Sarona a good choice and what is best for stairs?
There will be toddlers but no pets.
Judith
Thanks so much for answering my earlier question about the Bliss vs Smartstrand. We are only considering plush, so I should have explained that. Is the Bliss not very stain resistant? We have 2 kids and a dog.
Thanks again for your help. This blog/forum is very helpful!
Hi Jim :)
You've been so helpful to me in trying to pick out a carpet for my home. I asked about the Holletex (ultimate performance) carpet called Reliance and you told me it was excellent and would serve my purpose as I live out in the country (near seattle) with three cats.. I was all set to buy this carpet but after getting many samples none of the colors seem to work (I think they were all made for California as they are all peachy or green).. Is there another carpet with all those wonderful qualites of the Hollytex Reliance? There is a store nearby who just sells Tuftex (not sure of the spelling) but the carpet store I am dealing with can get any carpet I ask for. I feel like I am back to square one so I'd really appreciate your input as to another carpet with better color choices. Thank you again.. JR
Judith,
Sonora Smartstrand is mostly available from Horizon and Karastan lines from Mohawk Carpet Mills. Non Sonora smartstrand is also available from the Galaxy division of Mohawk. The Galaxy brand will wear just as well, and is less money. Look for a Galaxy brand called Power Play. This textured plush is in expensive, but will work well in a vacation home. It will clean up like no carpet you have had in the past. A retail installed cost would be less than three dollars per square foot; including pad.
Hope this helps,
Jim
Melissa,
Yes the Smartstrand will be easier to clean than the Bliss nylon. I would purchase the Smartstrand if the construction of the two choices are similar.
Good Luck,
Jim
JR,
If you want a carpet with the same or better properties as the Hollytex product, you should visit your Mohawk carpet dealer. Ask for Smartstrand products from Galaxy, Horizon or Karastan Mills (all owned by Hohawk). There are some plush carpets made from the new Triexta fiber (Smartsrand) that will work well in your case.
For fun, visit Youtube and enter "smartstrand challange" in the search window.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim I may be posting this twice.. about the Mohawk carpet dealer selling smartstrand.. one of the few places I can find selling it in my area is home depot but I recall you saying to stay away from those kinds of stores for carpeting.. is that correct?
JR
Great site, thanks. We're in Sherwood, and we'll definitely come in to see you soon. We have three bedrooms that need carpet. Using your formula, I come up with 63 yards. I have no idea what to budget for this. We usually buy quality products that last, and we plan to stay in the house for 10+ years. We love the Berber style, and of course, wool. But maybe we're shooting for the stars here. would love to stick around the $2000 price range. What can we expect to pay for an installed product? cash and carry? Thanks -Brady
JR,
In my opinion, Home Depot is a "crap shoot" at best. There must me a dealer in your area that carries Mohawk carpet.
Good luck,
Jim
We recently bought a house that was built in 2002. The problem is that the previous owner had large dogs and there is a smell in the house that I feel is most likely from the carpet (although it's not a urine smell). We've had it cleaned, but the smell is still there. While the most apparent fix would be to replace the carpet, it is not currently in our budget. My next thought is to take up the carpet, clean and prime the underlayment,replace the pad, and then reinstall the carpet. What is your opinion/suggestion?
Brady,
A high quality solution dyed nylon berber, (will not fade or stain)installed over our best 8 lb virgin rebond padding will cost you $2460. This full service sale price includes moving furniture, pull up and disposal of old carpet pad, cleaning the floor of old dirt and dust, installing the new pad and carpet by our craftsmen, vacuuming the job, and putting the furniture back.
If you wanted to save some money, you could move the furniture and deduct $125. If you were to pull up the old carpet and pad and pull out all the old staples, and clean the floor and dispose of the old carpet and pad, you can deduct another $125.
If you had your own carpet layer whom you trusted, you could take advantage of our cash n carry program. In this program you need to have your installer measure the job, and then come to me with the exact amount of carpet you need to order. Then you could buy this same carpet for $1231.00, and the same quality pad for $205. If your installer only charges you $325 you total cost would be $1761.00. The $700 you save means you give up the following: No Visa, No warranty from Carpet Classics, no recourse with the Contractors Construction Board, and furthermore, you must pay all the money upfront when you place the order. Cash n Carry orders are all priced FOB our shop in Tigard.
This is just one example, Brady. Please visit our showroom except for Oct 4th, as we will be closed for inventory.
Good Luck,
Jim
If the previous owner of your 2002 home had large animals, the smell is most likely coming from the pad. There is a possibility that the chipboard underlayment may have some issues that could be corrected with products like Kiltz. If you are going to go to all that work, I'd find a way to at least replace the carpet in the most suspected area of the odor.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim,
I found smartstrand at a local Abbey carpet store.. So far I like the one's from Karastan called Woodland Pass and Enviable.. they also carry their own namebrand from Mohawk under the label Alexnader smith (they are all smartstrand).. Do you have any opinons on any of these carpets??
Thank YOU!
JR
Regardless of the "mill name" on the back of the sample, carpets made of Triexta (Smartstrand) of equal specs will perform equally. The only difference is that some smartstrand is made form a smaller diameter fiber (small denier) than others, and these will tend to feel softer to the touch.
Good luck,
Jim
Hi Jim!
I'm Jessica. I'm an Interior Design major here at Brigham Young University Idaho.
I'm doing a presentation on carpet padding for the sophomore's.
My one question is: what chemicals are damaging to the different kinds of padding during the cleaning process?
I'm also wondering what advice you would give to the sophomore's as we prepare to enter into the working field.
Thanks for your help and time!
-Jessica
Stairs. Are there any known do's or do not's for the type of carpet you should use (or avoid) for stairs?
13 stairs from main floor to bedroom area - much trafficked - visible to guests when entering the home.
Jessica,
Professional carpet cleaners are trained and certified. The process of certification includes the latest information regarding proper chemicals to include those harmful to current paddings. Exactly what these chemical are are not in the scope of being an Interior Designer. Any household chemicals that would damage the padding will also damage the carpet. These chemicals include bleaches, solvents, and soaps with a PH higher than 7.
The majority of carpet in America is made my the big three; Shaw, Mohawk , and Beaulieu of America.
Good Luck,
JIm
Those carpets that should be avoided on stairs are long shags, loose loops, and super thick plush carpets.
Also, padding should not exceed over 7/16th of an inch thick.
Good Luck,
Jim
I am looking to replace my medium-grade Karistan carpet over the next six months and want to get a high-end Karistan or Stainmaster carpet, but I am also very interested in the pad. I live in a smaller condo on the top floor so noise, vibration, AND appearance are very important to me. Do you know anything about the Mohawk SmartCusion pad and how it compares to the slab rubber (which I understand is one of the most durable of pads), especially in my circumstances where there is only one way in and out of my unit.
I would feel more comfortable getting advice from you before I begin my search for the perfect carpet/price/installation. I was also glad to learn that the best place to buy from is a local carpet company rather than a large warehouse/chain where carpet might be comparable, but installation questionable.
Sincerely,
PJ
PJ,
Smartcushion by Mohawk is a 1/32 nd thicker than the standard 8 pound rebond. However it is made from memory foam, and has a vapor barrier on top. This pad will muffle the sounds as well as any. This pad will also double your warranty on any Smartstrand carpet. Mohawk uses the softer version of the Smartstrand fiber for their Karastan and Horrizon brands. You will get a much better, easier to clean, and fade proof carpet when made from Smartstrand than from Stainmaster .
Good Luck,
Jim
I just installed radiant heat. We removed our base boards and screwed aluminum plates between the floor joists with pex tubing. We are going to change our current carpet padding and not sure which one is the best for this. Does your website still hold true with the Frothed Foam being the best? I read on another website that Most experts agree that the Slab foam rubber pad is the best choice when it comes to carpet pads. I am not sure when that was written. Is there any new type of padding? Any help would be appreciated
Thank You
The best padding for your new radiant heated floor would be Healthier Choice Blue. It is 5/16th thick and has a low R rating. Also, unlike rubber will not deteriorate from the heat.
Good Luck,
Jim
Which is better Puresque carpet or magic fresh??? We have pets and I want something to help withthe odor.
Puresque is a Home Depot name for carpets made with "Magic Fresh".
JIm
I am recarpeting my living room, dining room and master bedroom. I am leaning towards Mohawk’s Horizon Collection Smart Strand. I found a Stainmaster Visco memory foam pad I like very much. I have also looked at Mohawk's Smart Cushion, but don’t like the feel as well. The problem is that my small wholesaler carries the Smart Cushion, but has not been able to find a distributor for the other. I am wondering if you can give me a lead on a distributor that I can pass on. (Colorado) Is this a good choice of pad for the Horizon Smartstrand?
You have chosen wisely with your choice of Smartstand from Horizon by Mohawk. I would strongly suggest you consider the SmartChusion pad for your Smartstrand carept. It is firmer and a better support than the Stainmaster pad, and will DOUBLE the warranty on the Horizon carpet.
Good Luck,
Jim
I am about to buy new carpet for my whole house. I am single and have no pets. I am leaning toward a frieze.
This is the first time I have shopped for carpet.
A local dealer recommended a carpet from Phenix called Sag Harbor. It is made of a fiber called 'Lifestrand.'
I didn't see either of these mentioned in posts that I read here in your blog.
What is your opinion of this company and/or fiber?
Lana,
Phoenix Carpet is a private label name, and I have no way of knowing who really makes this carpet. It is often found at Flooring America Franchises. The "Lifestrand" could be anything, but my best guess is PET polyester. The dealer has to disclose just what the fiber is.
A frieze is a good choice, but make sure you are not really looking at a shag.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi Jim,
A lot of good information on your website. I was leaning towards the local dealer but now I will for sure. I have carpeting a weekend home and am curious as to your recommendation. We have 4 children and a dog. Realistically the house is used 3 days a week, 6 months a year or 80-90 days annually. Considering the value of the purchase vs the expected performance of a carpet used 75% less than average, would you still recommend the Mohawk Smartstrand or is there a better choice for my dollar?
Thanks.
Brian
Brain,
Smartstrand is still a good choice for you. Look at the Galaxy line from Mohawk, and you will find some value price carpet.
Good Luck
Jim
Jim...Thank you! Thank you! for this site!
I am deciding between Beaulieu Diva, face weight of 60 oz, twist of 6.09, 100% FiberEssense P.E.T. continuous Filament Polyester with Scothgard and Luxury Bac and Beaulieu Colonial Creek, face weight of 50 oz., 1-00% BCF Nylon.
The first is treated with Puresque and the second with Magic Scent which when I called Beaulieu I was told are essentially the same odor nautralizer.
My main concern is pet order and urine smells.
Both have been matched in price for the job by the two competing stores.
What is your opinion? Also...suggestions on the pad...it is being laid on concrete.
Thank you!!
Jane
Jane,
Regardless of the amount of fiber, I'd choose the carpet that was the most dense (had the fiber closest together). Both are gong to clean the same.
I would also use a pad that had a moisture barrier and had a density of 8 lbs per cubic foot.
I only hope that both dealers have qualified installer that follow the CR-105 guidelines.
Good Luck,
Jim
Thanks Jim...you are a gentleman and a scholar!
Brian
Hi Guru - I'm not sure if I need wall to wall or a big area carpet and hall runner for a bedroom and hallway. I have hardwood floors. My elderly mom has a bum leg and uses a quad cane. The wood is too slippery. The area rugs and the pads I got from Home Depot (thin) are slipping on the floor. I need a low pile so her foot will be steady and a pad that won't slip on the hardwood floor, but won't be really pillowy, because she needs stability under her leg and the cane. What are the best options for me??!! Thanks so much!
Hi Jim,
First of all, this is a great web site, very
informative.
I recently received some money from my
insurance company to replace some carpeting
that suffered some water damage. The claims
adjuster had a piece of the carpet analyzed
and found that it was XtraLife Tactesse by
Shaw Industries (Tufted textured Saxony,
gauge: 1/10 in., face weight: 56.7 oz,
Nylon/BCF, stiches per in.: 8.4, pile height:
0.73 in, Tufts per SQ in: 84).
He noted that Flooring America's "Clear
Elegance" (MasterLife) and Carpet One's
"Can You Dance" (MasterLife) are similar
modern equivalents to my damaged bedroom
carpeting.
If I have understood you correctly, I should
be looking for something like Mohawk's
Smartstrand Triexta PTT in Saxony for my
bedroom carpeting. If I go to my local dealer,
is that what I ask for? Do the 2 equivalents
fall into that category?
Thanks very much,
Steve H
Pembroke Pines, FL
Carie,
You best bet for your Mom's safety is a light weight commercial carpet installed over a 32 ounce fiber pad. This type of carpet and pad will feel firm under foot while giving some warmth to the floor.
To go back to hardwood floors after this type of install, you will have to refinish the hardwood.
Good Luck,
Jim
You are wise to choose Smartstrand instead of Xtra life Stainmaster. The Xtra Life Stainmaster nylon is way over hyped in my opinion. In practical experience, I have found Smartstrand to be a superior product.
Ask your dealer for Atlantic Shores by Horizon from Mohawk. For an Upgrade, ask for Intelligent Style , also by Horizon form Mohawk Industries. These two will out perform your old carpet, and may even survive your next water incident.
Good Luck,
Jim
I want to place wall to wall carpeting on my floors over the laminate flooring(it is in very good condition) that is in place now. My question is whether the laminate has to be removed before installing the carpet.
I would prefer not to do that but if it is necessary can the laminate be pulled up without much damage and can it be stored/saved in the attic and/or reused?
Thanks.... cp
Hi Jim,
Trying to follow your advice on
dealing with a small, trusted firm.
I spoke with one today that is
A-rated by the local BBB.
Apparently, they are a Mohawk
ColorCenter. The salesperson that I
spoke with told me that they sell
Aramacao SmartStrand carpeting,
which is exactly the same as
Horizon Atlantic Shores. For some
reason, a ColorCenter has to use
the name Aramacao rather than
Horizon. Does this make sense?
BTW, he quoted $42.24 psy
installed, including old carpet
removal and moving furniture
(I think that was padding too,
but I need to check back with him).
Thanks again,
Steve H
Pembroke Pines, FL
Thanks for the assist, Jim -- Carrie.
You laminate flooring will have to come up before you install wall to wall carpet that is stretched in over a pad.
Many of the laminates are the type that click together. If this is the case, you can carefully remove each board, and perhaps reinstall it in another area.
Good Luck,
Jim
Steve,
The Color Center dealer gets special names on their carpet to keep comparison shopping at a minimum. This is standard fare these days with all the special programs offered by all the mills. The specs for their version of Atlantic Shores are most likely the same, and a price of $42 per yd installed with full service and pad, is not out of line.
Good Luck,
JIm
What a terrific site chock full of useful information!
We plan to recarpet our downstairs. We've visited a few local flooring stores and have identified several styles of carpet we like. We're giving serious consideration to 1) Shaw Design Texture Platinum (ANSO nylon), 2) Mohawk New Sensation (Triexta) and 3) Hollytex Sugar and Spice (Stainmaster Tactesse nylon). The salesperson at one of the stores is pushing the Shaw carpet, which is on sale, over the Mohawk. His argument is that nylon has been around a lot longer than Triexta and has withstood the test of time. Any help you can give us concerning the relative quality of these three choices will be greatly appreciated. For the record, we have two cats with their claws intact that occasionally have "accidents" (vomit and hairballs, not urine) on our carpets.
Jeff,
I am not sure the "New Sensations" is made with the same twist level as the other two carpets you are looking at. If the face weights of these carpets are similar, then they will all perform as far as wear goes. However, the Triexta will not only wear well, but will not fade, and will be the easiest carpet to clean you have owned.
Good Luck,
Jim
You are welcome, Steve.
Hello,
We've gotten a quote on some stainmaster (3rd generation?) Luxerelle with tiffany cushion and after reading your site I'm thinking another brand may be just as good/better with better value. Beaulieu manufacturer, one was style ultralife other activelife - do you have some other recommendations I can research? Thanks in advance
You can do better in the Beaulieu line if you looked at some of their "permasoft plus " line of solution dyed
nylon carpet.
This line of carpet will not fade, and the stain resistance is the best available, even better than SmartStrand. The only draw back to this type of carpet is the limited color selection.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi,
I'd like your opinion on a textured saxony with a face weight of 58.80 100%smartstrand bcf triexta fiber, don't have twist but 8.10 stitches per inch, will install over 6 lb pad for $1735/378sq ft - also can you tell me what WFL means on back of carpet samples?
Thank you
The 58 ounce Triexta carpet you are looking at for $1735 appears to be a good buy. I would upgrade the pad to SmartCushion by Mohawk if you area is a high traffic area, and you are going to be in the home for more than five years.
WFL is not an acronym I am familiar with.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi! What a wonderful website and bulletin board you have here. I can't believe you are willing to take so much time to help so many people who will probably never be in a position to purchase from you.
We are carpeting our steps and entire second floor. So far I've gone to one flooring showroom and spoken to one retailer/installer who comes to your home. Both received VERY good reviews at www.angieslist.com, which is the reason I chose them.
However, both of them have given me SOME information that I think is questionable and would like to confirm with you.
1. The showroom salesman said that Karastan is very choosy about the retailers they will deal with. He said their installers have to go for bi-annual refreshers/certification from Karastan. He said it used to be annual but now is every 2 years. Is this true?
2. I asked the "in home shopping" salesman/owner if he could get Karastan carpeting and he started to tell me that Karastan was Shaw. I said, no, I was pretty sure it was a separate company and pulled out my Droid phone and went to www.karastan.com. Then he said that Shaw had a STYLE of carpet called Karastan. I find it hard to believe a company would name one of their lines after a competitor. But I do notice that all these flooring companies seem to have their own labels of brands, as you mention on one of your pages, so I wanted to check if this is true someplace. It sounds so stupid, I'm almost tempted to erase the question but I won't. Then he said he could get any carpet from any mill ... which, of course, directly contradicts the "choosy Karastan" comment of salesman #1. The in-home selling guy had GREAT, PHENOMENAL reviews ... and LOTS of them ... at Angies List.
You seem to mostly recommend 8 lb padding. At the store, the salesman showed me the 10 lb padding (by Stainmaster?) and told me that it increases the texture retention warranty on the Karastan carpets. What do you think of the 10 lb padding?
You often recommend Karastan's SmartStrand carpets – and I did like them. But I also liked the softness of Shaw's Tigressa line. I ended up with my choices being:
Karastan SmartStrand
- Embraceable
- Essential Living
Karastan with Scotchgard
- Cambridge Shores
Shaw Tigressa
- Suma Ultimate
- Suma Premiere
- Sultana Premiere
We want the same (fairly light colored) carpet for the stairs and the entire second floor. The stairs and our bedroom are high traffic acres, of course. Would you recommend strongly in favor or against any of these choices?
Well, I'd better stop here. This post is getting to be of War and Peace proportions. Thanks again for maintaining these sites and for answering my questions!
- Ann
Ann,
You are best to purchase form a full fledged dealer, and not an installer working out of his home. The installer may be fantastic at his trade, and hence the good reviews from Angies List. However, if you ever needed warranty work, it would be difficult to get mill support from an installer with no established roots.
Your selections are both good, and will wear well. If your home has kids, and or pets, I would suggest the Smartstrand.
The best pad for the Shaw carpet is triple touch pad from Shaw, and the best pad for the Smartstrand carpet is Smartcushion by Mohawk. Both of these pads double the factory warranty respectively.
Hope this helps,
Jim
Your best pad is triple touch pad for your
Oh, and is it true that only select dealers can sell "real" Karastan carpeting? If I do pick the Karastan, I want the real stuff!
- Ann
Ann,
It is true that only authorized Karastan dealers can sell Karastan carpets. Some installers will buy the carpet at a reduced rate from the Karastan dealer, and then he will mark it up to make a profit. However, if there is a problem with the carpet, you will find yourself ending up working with the Karastan dealer for resolution.
Mohawk owns the Karastan name, and the mill makes many carpets using smartstrand that are identical in specs to the Karastan brand, but the colors will be slightly different. Mohawk makes Smartstrand carpets under the Horizon label, and the Aladdin label. The carpets under the Horizon Mill name closely match those carpets made from Smartstrand under the Karastan name.
Good luck,
Jim
Jim,
Thanks for the wealth of information you provide to us carpet shoppers!
We have looked at the Mohawk SmartStrand Sorona Superior Style which is a 75 Oz. pile / face weight. Is the Sheer Ecstasy the same exact product? Are the color names and numbers the same? We like the Mohawk Smart Cushion Pad with the additional extended warranty. Subfloor is concrete which is 18 years old.
Sheer Extacy and Superior Style are both made from the same Smartstrand fiber, and the specs are the same, however, the colors are different.
Your choice of SmartCushion is a wise one, and you will love the way this carpet feels on concrete on that pad.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim,
I have searched the Mohwak web sites Floorscapes and Horizon Collections for further techincal info. on both style names. Neither show up on Mohwaks sites. Do you know what collection these two style names belong to?
Thanks for you great advice!
Mohawk, like other big mills, market their products under so many different names, it is almost impossible to find style names that match what you may see at a dealer.
The only website that contains technical info is mohawknet.com, a website for dealers only. Many dealers are not computer knowledgeable enough to use it. Even then, Mohawk does not even give the dealers all the specs on every one of their products. As a result I cannot answer your question with any confidence.
Good Luck,
Jim
I removed carpet for a client to check the condition of what turned out to be beautiful oak floors that have been covered for 40+ yrs. The padding underneath the carpet was waffle rubber and had decomposed to a gummy, thick coating in some areas and a hard rubber coating in other areas. There were other areas on the same floor in the same room where the padding was the powdery substance expected of its breakdown over a long time. Both of the other compositions have bonded to the floor. The same padding was used for the stairwell and second floor hallway and the padding had decomposed to the powdery substance. Regardless of why this happened (though I suspect heat from crawlspace ductwork played a factor), my client wants to attempt to remove the padding that has bonded to the floor and see what condition the floor would be in thereafter. Is there a product that could possibly remove the bonded padding and prevent having to refinish the floor or would the floors have to be refinished regardless of the product (should there be one) used to remove the bonded padding? The hesitation for just stripping and refinishing the floors is that the property is lived in by a 90 yr old woman that cannot easily be displaced for the time period required to refinish the floors properly. She sometimes uses a walker and finds carpeting a hinderance.
Thank you in advance for any input you may have
The rubber padding that has turned to "goo" is a serious problem as it is not easily removed. The use of solvents is required, and they will interact with the finish of the existing hardwood coatings.
You need to hire hardwood professional to view first hand the condition of the floor and the "goo". He may have some more ideas than me.
If you decide to recarpet, I suggest a commercial style carpet installed over a spun fiber pad.
Good Luck,
Jim
Carpet Jim,
We are comparing the following Karastan collections:
Embraceable
Essential Living
Do you have any numbers on the difference of pile or face weights of the two?
We have a subfloor of concrete which is 20 years old.
Please suggest a excellent pad to compliment either style. We have no notions of selling our home for along time.
Thanks, Carpet Jim!
Since I am not a Karastan dealer, I am not privy to the specs of the entire line of their carpets. I once in a while come across one of their styles that is an exact copy of another Mohawk carpet that I carry. Mohawk owns Karastan.
I did not see any mention of fiber in your comment. Is it nylon, or smartstrand ??. Regardless, the new Smartcushion will work great with your selection. This pad is made from memory foam and has a vapor barrier. It will double the warranty on your Karastan carpet. (Karastan may have their own name for this pad other than Smartcushion).
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim:
First of all, thank you very much for your obvious passion of helping people with your extensive knowledge. I don't think there are to many people who care like you do out there. We have recently remodeled and want to put a luxerious type of carpet in our new master bedroom which will meet up with dark engineered distressed/handscrapped maple floors in the sitting area. After reading your site, I don't want to make the mistake of wrong selection. I previously purchased carpets while my husband was deployed from Home Depot and it has worn terribly. I was given a sample of a Stainmaster Luxerell that we like for the pattern (small squares) the feel, thickness or plushness. I believe this was pretty pricey from Arizona Wholesalers. Any suggestions on similar type of carpet/pad maybe that wouldn't be as pricy for us to consider? We live in Az. just us & three dogs a 4 lb yorkie, 45 lb. healer & 70 lb lab. Jim, where would you recommend purchasing this type of carpet. We have learned of the frustrations of private labeling and now by reading your website extensively I know why thanks to you!
With gratitude in advance!
Jan
We are carpeting our intire house. (About 500 yds) The dealer told me that Carpet One has a carpet called Resista that is 100% BCF Resist Polyester that would be an awesome carpet for our house. I am not seeing good reviews on your site concerning this carpet. Will this mat? What are the cons to this carpet?
Jan,
Because you have dogs living in the home, I suggest you NOT purchase any carpet that has loops. This includes most all patterned carpet. Also, the patterned carpet will force you to buy extra carpet in order to match the pattern.
Instead, look for a frieze or a textured plush for this area. If you have any kind of animal accident problems, I would also suggest you look for carpets made from Smartstrand. (tirexta)
As far as price is concerned, you usually get what you pay for. If you are going to be in the home for over ten years, be prepared to spend over $4/sq ft installed with pad for anything decent. Add 50 cents per square foot if there is furniture to move.
Hope this helps,
Jim
Resista polyester is a private label name for PET filament polyester. The PET fiber is a great fiber if the carpet is well constructed. This means the twist level must be 6 or better, the face weight should be 40 ounces or better, and the pile has to be short and dense. Do no buy a longer shag.
If you have 500 sq yds of carpet you must live in a very big house (over 5000 sq ft of living space). I am assuming that you plan to stay in this home over 10 years. If this is the case, I would look at Smartstrand triexta carpet. This will give you a more cleanable carpet, and it will wear longer.
Good luck,
Jim
Speaking of frieze/shag..can anyone tell me the name of a vacumn that works well on this type? My warranty says no beater bar/brush...I know the specifics of the type of machine..just need a name of one that someone might have had good experience with on this type of carpet.please..i need to c=vacumn:)
With shag type carpets, I find that a medium to light weight vacuum works best. Try an medium priced upright that has a changeable bag ie. hoover, panasonic, or orecx. Stay away form kirby, royal, and dyson.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim,
We are looking at the Mohawk Smartstrand Superior Style AKA Sheer Esctasy saxony style 75 oz. pile weight with Smart Cushion pad.
We like the plush soft feel and properties of the Smartstrand.
What solution dyed Nylon carpet brand or name that is similiar to the Mohawk mentioned above? Plush pile weight and soft feeling of Smartstrand. In your blog I have noticed the Hollytex Reliance, which is in the 50 oz. area face weight. Any suggestions on higher pile weight? I like the H/C Green 7/16 pad to.
Thanks you so much!
Sheer Ecstasy is all ready the "rolls royce" of carpets, and any solution dyed nylon would be a step down to something like a Lexus.
If you want a luxurious solution dyed nylon, check out Hollytex's Durango 2, a 60 ounce soft plush.
Healthier Choice is a great pad, but if you install the Mohawk product, use Mohawk's "smartcushion" to double the already outstanding warranty on the Sheer Ecstasy.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim, thanks for all of the wonderful tips. We need to replace the carpet in my 85-year-old grandparent's home. Both have mobility issues and my grandfather is incontinent and uses a cane. They frequently drop food on the floor, too. The current carpet is 5 years old and smells awful, despite being cleaned fairly often. Any suggestions for type of carpet? Maybe carpet tiles? Should we avoid padding - even though we're concerned about falls? (We considered vinyl, but they also get cold so easily.) Is there some brand that offers more resistance to organic stains and bacteria?
Thanks for your help,
Michelle
Michelle,
Your perfect carpet will be a new triexta Smartstrand carpet from Horizon/Mohawk called Sacred Star. This short frieze installed over SmartCushion with vapor barrier will be the best for spills and traffic that includes walking shuffling feet. This carpet can be steam cleaned with plain water, and still get clean. The carpet carries the best warranties in the carpet business, and using the SmartCushion doubles this warranty.
Good Luck,
Jim
We've decided on Mohawk Windwalker for our living room, dining room and hallway and Mohawk Atlantic Shores for our two downstairs bedrooms. Both are Triexta. We had two local carpet businesses measure and give us price quotes. One recommends Mohawk SmartCushion for padding. We know that this will double parts of the warranty. The other recommends a Karastan luxury pad, which they claim will also double the warranty even though the carpet itself is not Karastan. It is a 22 lb. pad and is considerably more expensive. We assume that it is a rubber pad. Is it worth the extra cost over the SmartCushion?
Also, the Atlantic Shores was quoted at about $52 a square yard from the dealer who wants to use the SmartCushion. That includes installation, removal/disposal of old carpet, moving of furniture and freight. However, another poster (see October 19) said he was given a price of only $42 a square yard installed for the same carpet. Our dealer claims he can't go any lower and our other quote, with the more expensive pad, is higher. Are these fair prices in today's market?
Jeff,
The carpets you have chosen will last a long time, and the pad choice should not the reason you purchase from one dealer or the other. Both of the pads will more than do the job.
I would, however, get a complete quote and measurement from each of these dealers, and then see how close the final completed package price is for the entire job. The per yd price may be irrelevant if the two package prices are within 3% of each other.
Furthermore, prices in NY city and SFO are more expensive than in Boise , ID, or almost anywhere in Florida. Thus, what one blog commenter purchased a carpet for could be more related to where he lives.
Good Luck,
Jim
My wife came home with an estimate from Carpet One(after they came and measured).The living room 14x20 and stairs(13)and upstairs hallway will be done w/Lees Unforgettable(100% evertest)which is triexta.The pad is 7/16 foam urethane throughout whole installation.Two bedrooms approx14x12 done in Costa Mesa 100%nylon/20 yr warranty as opposed to lifetime in LR.$5k,includes install,move furniture,discard old,and two remnant borders.EVERYTHING! Is this a good deal?(TOP of line LR)in Lees ladder.Reasonable?
It is hard to tell if you are getting a fantastic deal or not, as Carpet One has all their products private labeled. Therefor, your "Lees" carpet (which is made by Mohawk because they are the only mill making carpet out of Triexta) could be found under the Mohawk label at a Mohawk dealer for less money in most cases. However, the remnants and the boarder work, combined with what appears to be a premium pad, makes this deal worth the investment. This is especially true if this Carpet One dealer has a good reputation in your community. This means that if something goes amiss during the job, you stand a good chance of the dealer making it right at no expense to you.
Good Luck,
Jim
Confused: We are installing carpeting over radiant heat. We were told by several dealers \(also wholesale suppliers) to use a rubber pad. waffle. Help, the pad has been purchased, full rolls since it was bought from a wholesaler,. What is the correct pad over radiant heat ?
Over radiant heated floors you can install slab rubber pad, spun fiber pad, or froth foam. If the people who installed the radiant heat insist that you use a certain type of pad, you need only do so if it is necessary for the warranty of the radiant heat source.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi!
My sister-in-law bought some area rugs that have some kind of coating on them that rubs off on feet and are making her hardwood floors really slippery. Are there any solutions for this problem?? P.S. I bought Smartstrand carpet from the type of dealer you recommended and I love it! Thanks for all of the great advice!
Many area rugs have a coating like teflon used to protect from spills. This coating can rub off and transfer to laminate or hardwood floors. This makes the floor slippery.
You can have the area rug professionally cleaned, and this will cut down on the amount of teflon like substances on the carpet, and also the amount transfered to your other floors.
BTW Smartstrand carpets have no teflon or other coatings on them. Thus no transfer of chemicals, and no off gassing of such.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi Jim,
I have read and read, but I think I get more confused. I am looking at frieze in Shaw Anso Nylon BCF Nylon with R2X, softbac with a traffic rating of 4.0. I keep reading about the SmartStrand triexta--will they both wear the same and what are the advantages of either? I am putting the carpet in the den, and all the bedrooms. I live alone and have a small dog that does have accidents and 3 grandsons that visit often (all toddlers). The dealer uses an 8lb rebond pad.
Also I have looked at a Shaw shag-Anzo Nylon BCF with RX2 with a wear rating of 4.5 and I am thinking about putting it in the den and master bedroom. Would that be crazy. I haven't seen it laid in a house before, but I like it- I guess because it is different and not like the old shag that I remember.
I appreciate your thoughts on all of this. Both of the Shaw products say they have a 20 year stain warranty. My largest concerns are the puppy and her accidents and matting because of one traffic pattern that I can't get rid of.
Thank you,
Lisa
Lisa,
You may use either fiber system, but for performance the construction must be dense and not shag like.
The key to keeping your carpet looking good is also related to the quality of the maintenance you give it.
A good upright will work except a kirby, dyson, or royal. Those brands are too hard on the carpet. Regular commercial cleaning is also an absolute must in order to keep your mill warranty.
Good Luck,
Jim
My budget for my 715 square feet is only $1,600. I've been rearcing online & no what is good, but Nylon is not in my budget. I read poor reviews, from HD, Loews & Empire. I had Empire just do measurements. HD I was told Polyester isn't how it used to be made & its has a 10yrs stain & 10 wear warranty. The carpet is Looptex 30-35 peace of mind toffe with the 8lb pad. This is a twist carpet. I read bad reviews about Looptex as well. Is this a junk carpet or will it last. No pets, & grandkids on wkends. I need to know in 2days thnx
I do not have any information on Looptex Mills, but if the carpet has a high twist rate, and the fiber is filament PET polyester, it should hold up for at least seven years if you have it professionally cleaned every two years.
The carpet should be installed according to CR-105 for best results. Seams need to be sealed, and the use of a power stretcher is a must.
Many dealers and home centers do not follow these guidelines (this keeps their labor cost down)and as a result you could have NO warranty in the event of a claim.
BTW you should have someone besides Empire measure you job. You wisest decision was NOT to buy from them.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hello Carpetguru--
Thanks for the great website. We're planning to install wool carpet, and we're confused about the padding we should use. We want comfort and durability, and we're concerned about the environment. Years ago, Healthier Choice foam was mentioned in your blog. On the site, you now talk about Shaw's foam product. Since we're using wool, what would you recommend. Thanks, Marc
I don't know if you still respond to this blog, but here goes. We are finishing our basement and are looking at a Shaw carpet that is 100% BCF Cleartouch PET Polyester. We don't want to put a lot of money into the carpet due to moisture concerns, as it is a basement. We have not had water in there since we've lived here. Is this a good carpet? It is a short frieze or shag. Thanks for your help.
Marc,
Use either HC green or Shaw's triple touch froth foam 8 lb version. Both will last a lifetime. Both are about the same price, so I would use which ever you are able to find.
Good Luck,
Jim
If the ClearTouch PET carpet you are looking has a par rating of 3.75 or more, then you will be happy with the results.
PET will not be affected by the moisture, however the backings could suffer form excess wetness. Use a good pad WITHOUT a moisture barrier.
Good Luck,
Jim
Thank you for your reply re. the BCF Clearouch PET polyester carpet. I found information online that showed it had a 3.75 rating (it didn't say PAR), so I think it's a decent carpet. We are also considering (for a lot less money, approx. $1.75 per sq.ft.) a Harding carpet called Freeman Best. However, I guess Harding Carpet is a private label carpet of ProSource Flooring (which is where we are getting it thru our contractor), and I can't get any info. on it. The saleslady did not know what a PAR rating was and asked if I had found that term online. :) She didn't know its PAR rating. I can't find out any info. on Harding carpet online, much less their Freeman carpet. Have you heard of them? Thank you again for your time; you are providing an invaluable service!
Pro Source, like Carpet One, is big into private labeling their products. This prevents you from shopping and comparing. "Harding" is not a carpet mill, and carpets with that name could be made by anyone. In your case, see if the words "magic fresh" are on the sample. If so, your "harding" carpet is made by Beaulieu of America.
If you cannot find out what the par rating is, then perhaps you should stick to those carpets where you find the par rating available.
Good Luck
Jim
We are planning to replace 16 year old wool carpet in living, dining, halls, and stairs. Decorator that I am working with has found a carpet that we like from a company called Lonesome Oak Trading Co. from their McEntire Collection. It seems to be a short twisted shag @70 oz. I have never heard of this company and can't find out much. Carpet is polyester. Can you help? MJ
MJ,
Lonesome Oak is a medium sized mill in GA. It does over $150 million a year in sales, and specializes in high twist solution dyed PET products. The collection you mentioned is excellent, and I even feature it in our showroom.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim, I'm in Houston now, but years back (1968) I, too, graduated from Lake Oswego High School. Small World.
I have just purchased a 1970 10' x 14' Persian rug and want to put a quality pad under it. Would the Healthier Choice 10lb White 1/2" be a good choice? Would the Shaw Triple Touch be about the same? How about the Duratech 12lb 7/16" padding?
Lastly, any suggestions for a good place to purchase any of these pads on line by the roll?
Thanks, Selby
Selby,
You best pad for under your area rug is not any kind of froth foam. You need a specialty pad that has a rubber coating on one side and a vellcro like surface on the other. This pad is composed of fiber in the middle. You will find it at better area rug dealers. You will not find it online for such a small piece.
Good Luck,
Jim
I am carpeting my entire home. I am torn between two different carpets. One is soft but the other has the look I am hoping to achieve. Ultimately performance is my biggest concern with two small children. They are both Hollytex ultimate performance/solution dyed Nylon carpets .
Here are the specs, I also want to know if I should use the 6lb ½” or 8lb ½” rebond pad.
Durango 2
85 Weight
119.84 Total weight
5100 Density
3.5 PAR
20/32 Pile height
Textured
4.57 Twist
1/10 gauge
Palm Springs 2
75 weight
110.87 Total weight
2755 Density
4.0 PAR
1” Pile Height
Frieze
5.5 Twist
1/8 gauge
I will wait for your response before I order. Thanks
Which ever carpet you use, Palm Springs, or Durango, you should use an 8 lb pad. I'd suggest 7/16ths rather than 1/2 inch.
Durango is a plush type carpet, while Palm Springs is a shag type carpet. They will look and perform differently. The Durango will be harder to seam, show footprints and vacuum marks, and will tend to be more formal than Palm Springs. The Palm Springs carpet is very tightly twisted, and thus will stand up to heavy traffic better than ordinary shag type carpets.
There is a style called Park Ave 2 that is a cross between Durango and Palms springs (same color line as Palm springs in solid colors only), and still not as soft as Durango. I have found that after the carpet gets installed, people don't spend a lot of time feeling the carpet with their hands. Park Ave 2 is a true frieze, and not shaggy like Palm Springs.
All of these carpets are so well made, that wear should not be your concern. Pick the carpet that meets your lifestyle.
Hope this helps,
Jim
I am looking to replace my carpet following a water gusher from my washing machine. ITEL report came back, giving detailed specs. I am having a hard time acquiring similarly detailed specs for some of the carpets that I am considering as a replacement. Insurance has given me a budget of $4.20 (material cost only), which I don't think is allowing me to purchase a replacement carpet as nice as what I had. I've asked for an increase in the budget. Is there a good source for getting the detailed specs? I notice that some posters here have been able to obtain those.
I've been looking at a Masland Stainmaster BCF nylon Luxurell "Posh" and I do have the specs for that. I'm also considering a Karastan Bella Villeta made of triexta (if I can get over having something other than nylon), but I'm not sure the Bella Villeta has the density I would like.
Color is a big issue for me and my selections are limited if I insist on a pale yellow carpet. Stain protection is also a must (2 cats who occasionally spit up). They also like to scratch carpet - mostly on the stairs, although I have all sorts of scratching posts for them.
Any thoughts? On where to secure specs on carpets (including on some others I'm looking at) and on the two front contenders?
Also, how would either of the two front runners do with a Dyson vacuum - the one that is designed for use when you have pets.
Thank you. Loving your site. It has really helped to educate me. Meg
Meg,
It is always difficult dealing with insurance companies. They are not always knowledgeable about current carpet technology or price trends. I don't know how old your carpet was, but you should save a piece of it to take to your local carpet dealer. He should be able to find you something of equal value.
Nylon and Triexta will wear well and you should be making your choice based on feel and color; assuming you have chosen a carpet that is similar in construction to your old carpet.
Masland and Karastan are both high end brands, and they tend to be a little over priced. Masland, a division of the Dixie Group, is the most expensive brand. Karastan, a division of Mohawk industires, is a little less pricey.
Finding the specs on any one piece of carpet is a little bit of work, and you need to find a dealer that will work with you and has access to the mill via computer. At our store, we have direct access to the mills computer (only for the carpets we display). This helps us in finding the specs on most carpets we carry. Sometimes, however, the mill does not supply all the specs we request.
If being stain proof is important, then the triexta will come closer to meeting this requirement. However, no carpet is completely stain proof.
Good Luck,
Jim
I am looking at two carpets:
Mohawk SP511 which is a 100% Ultrstrand BCF Nylon with Scotchguard Protector and Stain Release, a 38 ounce frieze 2307 density and a Shaw Embellishment (j) 100% Evertouch R2X Stain resistance Nylon 44 ounce frieze 1927 density. Using an 8 # 7/16 " rebond with woven mesh top. Am I on the right track and which carpet should I choose?
Jim, thank you for your response. I've actually been to about 8 different carpet stores with a sample of my own carpet in hand (it is about 10 years old - tufted saxony, quite dense). I've also included also taken the ITEL report with me.
It's been a frustrating experiencing. They can show me something comparable to what I had, but it doesn't fit the price point the insurance company has given me based on the ITEL report. and the ITEL report references carpets no longer in existence to provide the pricing benchmark. Insurance company has made a step in my direction - asking for two written estimates on the 2 carpets I am most likely to want. The carpets are 2.50 to 3.50 over the price point.
Jim:
I am a floor-covering dealer that mostly dabbles in the property management market (apartments, retirement homes, etc) and I want to thank you for this informative forum. Carpet fiber, construction, style, installation, and maintenance all go into the equation when selecting a quality carpet.
I appreciate your insight and look forward to following your blog.
The Shaw Embellishment is the better of the two.
good luck,
Jim
Keep working with your insurance company. You may be surprised how much they want to keep your business.
Good Luck,
Jim
Gary,
Thanks for you kind words.
Jim
Jim, Thank you for the information on the Shaw Embellishment. We are building a home and I have been overwhelmed with all of the choices. Will I be happy with that choice or should I choose an even better carpet. I want a carpet that does not show every footprint. I had a very plush carpet before and you could see every print. Any advise would be helpful. Thanks again...
Because I do not have a sample of your "embellishmnet"
I am not sure of the texture of the carpet. I was going on the specs you provided. If the carpet is a frieze, it will show less footprints than a plush or textured plush. You could ask the dealer to order you a larger sample of the carpet for you to take home and "live on" for a few days.
Good Luck,
Jim
Hi Jim,
I just had Shaw Design Twist Gold in both of the secondary bedrooms and Design Twist Platinum in the Den and Master bedroom. It is installed over a 6 lb 1/2" pad. The secondary bedrooms are fine. I have a 7 lb dog and you can tell every step she takes in the den/master. It is driving me crazy-every morning I get up and vacuum. The salesperson said to give it a couple of weeks for the carpet to blossom and after a few vacuums it should be alright. Is this right? Both are 100% nylon and it feels great to walk on. Is this because the platinum is more dense than the gold? Sorry I don't have the face weight, they did say they didn't put private labels on their carpet.
Footprints are going to show on plush or textured plush carpets. The fact that your dog's paw prints are visible is normal and will not "go away". The thicker the plush, the more visible the footprint.
Good Luck,
Jim
Jim, the Design Twist carpet that I am having trouble with is supposed to be a frieze. It looked like it when it was rolled up before the installation. Should paw prints show in frieze also?
A true frieze has a very low pile height, and is so tightly twisted that the surface almost looks curly. The carpet your salesperson called a frieze is most likely what we used to call a "short shag". Today salespeople are afraid to use the "S" word in fear of loosing a sale.
Good Luck,
Jim
My friends just put in new carpet and used a memory foam carpet pad. It feels very soft and wonderful to walk on but I am concerned about how well it will hold up and how it will effect the carpets durability. Do you know about this product and have some advice?
Christie
Post a Comment